RevLeft
Go Back   RevLeft > General > Learning
Register Blogs FAQ Members List RevLeft Groups Chat Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Learning A place for beginners and learners to ask their political questions about theory or specific issues. Don't worry if you think your questions are stupid or pointless, ask away. Learning is not stupid and is never pointless.

Forum Led by: Global Moderators, Admin

Donation Goal
Goal amount for this month: 100 USD, Received: 0 USD (0%)
Donate Now
Do you like RevLeft? Help keeping RevLeft alive and donate to cover the increasing running charges!
Donation History

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools
  #1  
Old 9th February 2010, 09:22
Leaf's Avatar
Leaf Leaf is offline
Junior Revolutionary
 
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 57
Rep Power: 2
Reputation: 16
Leaf is on a distinguished road
Default Conservative, propaganda garbage. Refutes please

"Communism can never work, because the more productive people will always have more than the less productive people, and the only institution which can take from the productive and give to the unproductive is an all powerful state with the ability to control everyone's lives.

In such an environment, only the most brutal, ruthless people rise to the top, ensuring that for every communist regime, there will be an unelected, unaccountable, unstoppable, psychopathic murderer as leader. "

I know it's crap but would love to hear revleft's rebuttal as I think I would learn from it, thank you
  #2  
Old 9th February 2010, 09:49
AnthArmo's Avatar
AnthArmo AnthArmo is offline
Question All Authority
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 169
Tendency: Anarchist
Rep Power: 4
Reputation: 113
AnthArmo will become famous soon enoughAnthArmo will become famous soon enough
Default

This sounds like its based entirely on a strawman argument. The Conservatard arguing this thinks that Communism = everyone has the same income. This is entirely false, Communism aims to bring about the end of Private Property. If anything, this requires the eventual elimination of a state.

Just tell him that Communists don't give a rats arse about Income equality, we care about "Power" equality.
__________________
"I'd rather be ruled by a mob than a tyrant" - Kwisatz Haderach
The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to AnthArmo For This Useful Post:
  #3  
Old 9th February 2010, 12:34
Comrade Lewis's Avatar
Comrade Lewis Comrade Lewis is offline
My e-peen brings all the boys
 
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Perth, Australia
Organisation: Socialist Alternative
Posts: 806
Tendency: Trotskyist
Rep Power: 7
Reputation: 513
Comrade Lewis is a glorious beacon of lightComrade Lewis is a glorious beacon of lightComrade Lewis is a glorious beacon of lightComrade Lewis is a glorious beacon of lightComrade Lewis is a glorious beacon of lightComrade Lewis is a glorious beacon of light
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Leaf View Post
"Communism can never work, because the more productive people will always have more than the less productive people, and the only institution which can take from the productive and give to the unproductive is an all powerful state with the ability to control everyone's lives.
Assuming the state is a dictatorship, indeed. But that would not be socialism. Socialism is democratic by definition.

Quote:
In such an environment, only the most brutal, ruthless people rise to the top, ensuring that for every communist regime, there will be an unelected, unaccountable, unstoppable, psychopathic murderer as leader.
Too bad that in a socialist country officials will be democratically elected, will not be given millions of dollars in support from billionaires (in exchange for tax breaks) and will be instantly recallable.

I hope there are people who don't still believe this, but I know I'm going to be disappointed.
__________________
'i would punch u in the jawside so hard it would lean more left than the ICC' - bailey_187 to AK
"why does using the acronym LGBT remind me of sandwiches all the time?" - psycho
"Now the states in the business of casually arresting successful protest groups at the end of fully automatics we really are going to have to be very clever about how we go about things if the far left movement grows.

("First they came for the half witted tossers")"
- Comrade Joe on the arrest of EDL members
  #4  
Old 9th February 2010, 12:57
Robespierre2.0's Avatar
Robespierre2.0 Robespierre2.0 is offline
authoritarian bureaucrat
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: 'Murika
Posts: 331
Tendency: Stalinists
Blog Entries: 1
Rep Power: 6
Reputation: 200
Robespierre2.0 has a spectacular aura aboutRobespierre2.0 has a spectacular aura aboutRobespierre2.0 has a spectacular aura about
Send a message via AIM to Robespierre2.0
Default

All governments are brutal and ruthless. Socialist governments direct that brutality towards the enemies of the workers, while capitalist governments direct it towards a scapegoat (jews, arabs, socialists, the 'evil clique').

As for productivity, your friend is viewing people from a very callous, economistic mindset. Why are some workers more productive than others in the first place?
(I'm assuming your friend has the mindset that sees skilled labor as more valuable)

Your friend can talk all he wants about social mobility, but by and large, that social mobility is only extended to those who have internalized capitalist values, and those who have internalized capitalist values tend to be the ones benefiting from them.

In other words, the fact that every so often one lucky black kid who grew up in the slums gets assistance paying for a college doesn't mean a thing. Usually those around him who don't 'succeed' in the educational system have realized early on that the system is rigged.
__________________
"Terror is nought but prompt, severe, inflexible justice." - Maximillien Robespierre



Formerly Cmde. Mantis
  #5  
Old 9th February 2010, 13:42
Raúl Duke's Avatar
Raúl Duke Raúl Duke is offline
Gonzo Anarchist
Committed User
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Florida or Puerto Rico
Organisation: Sympathizer of: NYMAA, RAAN, IWW
Posts: 2,483
Latest Blog Entry: Someone's post on the state
Rep Power: 17
Reputation: 1092
Raúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profound
Default

Quote:
Just tell him that Communists don't give a rats arse about Income equality, we care about "Power" equality.
You and I think similarly...
I used the same argument once (i.e. anarchism's focus is 'power' equality).

I agree with anthroarmo's post. The person is making a strawman (and most people do since they don't even know what communism is about) plus an odd one...

It's like he assumes there was income equality in the 'socialist' states but I doubt there was (at least for a long period of time).

Also, his mention of "because the more productive people will always have more than the less productive people" rises a red flag...

In capitalism, some of the least productive members get paid more. I remember a study which claim that a hospital cleaner did more good (and more in dollar amounts in some abstract way on analyzing productive work) than a banker (who I think the study determined wasted money, especially with the recent bail-out and bonus giving fiasco, instead of doing something productive that was valuable).
__________________
"My heart sings for you both. Imagine it singing. la la la la."- Hannah Kay

"if you keep calling average working people idiots i am sure they will be more apt to listen to what you have to say. "-bcbm
  #6  
Old 9th February 2010, 14:05
NecroCommie's Avatar
NecroCommie NecroCommie is offline
Marxist-Leninist
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Seinäjoki, Finland
Organisation: KomNL
Posts: 1,120
Blog Entries: 1
Rep Power: 8
Reputation: 596
NecroCommie is a name known to allNecroCommie is a name known to allNecroCommie is a name known to allNecroCommie is a name known to allNecroCommie is a name known to allNecroCommie is a name known to all
Send a message via ICQ to NecroCommie
Default

Besides, that douchebag seems to think of himself as some sort of übermensch, part of the "more productive" population and therefore worth more than a common man. Sounds terribly like he has some sort of hidden social darwinist agenda.
  #7  
Old 9th February 2010, 14:48
Raúl Duke's Avatar
Raúl Duke Raúl Duke is offline
Gonzo Anarchist
Committed User
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Florida or Puerto Rico
Organisation: Sympathizer of: NYMAA, RAAN, IWW
Posts: 2,483
Latest Blog Entry: Someone's post on the state
Rep Power: 17
Reputation: 1092
Raúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profoundRaúl Duke is profound
Default

Quote:
Besides, that douchebag seems to think of himself as some sort of übermensch, part of the "more productive" population and therefore worth more than a common man. Sounds terribly like he has some sort of hidden social darwinist agenda.
That's a possibility. I find it funny when Randroids speak of the capitalist class as the "productive class" and even funnier when the Randriods seem to think they qualify to be part of that "productive" class.
__________________
"My heart sings for you both. Imagine it singing. la la la la."- Hannah Kay

"if you keep calling average working people idiots i am sure they will be more apt to listen to what you have to say. "-bcbm
  #8  
Old 11th February 2010, 03:53
Wolves of Paris's Avatar
Wolves of Paris Wolves of Paris is offline
anti-capitalist
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Illinois
Posts: 458
Tendency: Collectivists
Rep Power: 5
Reputation: 303
Wolves of Paris is a jewel in the roughWolves of Paris is a jewel in the roughWolves of Paris is a jewel in the roughWolves of Paris is a jewel in the rough
Send a message via AIM to Wolves of Paris
Default

Communism doesn't require everyone to have the same amount of wealth. Obviously if worker X produces more than worker Y s/he will be compensated justly, if everyone was paid the same it would be a wage, which we oppose.

Communism is most importantly a classless society and we as Marxians view social classes in terms of their relation to the means of production if the means of production are collectively owned then social classes will disperse as will the state.
__________________

Closed Thread

Bookmarks

Tags
conservative, garbage, propaganda, refutes

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Lenin Refutes Newton Rosa Lichtenstein Philosophy 40 20th April 2009 09:54
NAFTA and globalization conservative propaganda spice756 Opposing Ideologies 6 29th November 2008 01:23
Ridiculus conservative propaganda! nvm Trashcan 0 20th June 2008 15:06
Lenin refutes mechanics Rosa Lichtenstein Philosophy 17 8th March 2006 18:45
Fueling the Conservative Propaganda Machine NY_Che21 RevLeft Articles 1 4th January 2005 01:13


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:59.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Zoints SEO v2.3.0 by Zoints & DxLwebs.com

Che Guevara Shirts, T-shirts, Tshirts, tees, merchandise